One rhetorical fallacy is oversimplification. This occurs
when an author tries to simplify a complex issue. The author overgeneralizes
the situation by leaving out vital information that can make the statement
false. For example, saying that eating carrots are healthy. Therefore, everyone
should eat carrots. However, this leaves out the problem that some people might
be allergic to carrots and cannot eat them. In addition, not all forms of
carrots are healthy. For example a person could put carrots in carrot cake and
say that it is healthy because it has carrots in it when in fact it is still
unhealthy. This fallacy can be seen in many writing genres. It can also appear
in everyday speech when people overgeneralize things by saying everyone does
this. Even the common phrase everyone is doing it is an example of oversimplification.
It is easy to be tricked by such a comment, especially when it is expertly
integrated into a person’s writing. However, many times it can make the issue
seem more confusing than it would if the issue was explained in detail. One
example of a person using oversimplification is Matt Walsh. In his article, “Isn’t
it Mean and Hateful to deport illegal immigrants?” he attempts to simplify the
issue and make it seem simpler than it actually seems. However, I became
confused in many parts of his article. Some parts I did not understand the
logic and I was unable to follow the argument. For example his statement “we
may be the first nation in the history of humanity that actually has to argue
over the basic concept of having and maintaining a border.” This statement
seems to make sense because all counties have borders that is simply a fact.
However, there are with so many countries in the world and in the history of
the world it is not reasonable to presume that none of these countries ever had
problems with maintaining borders. There are most likely a couple of other countries
dealing with immigration problems as well making it unreasonable to presume what
the author is saying. I was almost tricked by the author’s ploy, however, at a
closer look it is obvious that what the author is saying simply cannot be true.
To recognize this fallacy in the future I will pay closer attention to how the
author states their opinion and see if it makes sense. If the statement is oversimplified then there
will be a way to prove it wrong, otherwise it is most likely true. In most
causes however, the use of always, never, and only will most likely create an
oversimplification fallacy.
Friday, July 18, 2014
Thursday, July 17, 2014
Post Hoc and High Jumping
Since seventh grade I was a high jumper on my school’s
track and field team. I excelled and became confident in my abilities. However,
as many highly competitive athletes do, I had my superstitions. Superstitions
fall under the logos fallacy post hoc.
There were many instances in my high school high jump career where
superstitions were formed. I remember the first one being my sophomore year at
track sectionals. I hadn’t fixed my hair the same way I had the rest of the
season. Instead of a messy bun and a headband I put it in a simple ponytail. Through
the competition I noticed that my jumping was below my usual level. I was
scratching left and right, making careless mistakes, and barely clearing the
heights. As soon as I fixed my hair to its normal style my jumping improved immensely.
My coach just shook his head at me when I explained what I thought the problem
was and what I did to fix it. Starting my junior year I wore my hair with a
braid and a messy bun on the left side of my head. I never fixed my hair any
different way. Not once. Because of that one experience the way I fixed my hair
became an essential part of my jumping.
The next superstition to arise was related to food. I once ate a hamburger before I began my jumping competition. Bad idea. Instead of clearing my regular 5’2”, I only cleared 4’8”. Not only was a frustrated, I was reflective. I took note on what I had done differently and made the decision never to eat before a competition again. Though superstitious, and most coaches and athletes would disagree, this method worked for me. The next meet I didn’t eat before I jumped and I was back to clearing my 5’2”.
The next superstition to arise was related to food. I once ate a hamburger before I began my jumping competition. Bad idea. Instead of clearing my regular 5’2”, I only cleared 4’8”. Not only was a frustrated, I was reflective. I took note on what I had done differently and made the decision never to eat before a competition again. Though superstitious, and most coaches and athletes would disagree, this method worked for me. The next meet I didn’t eat before I jumped and I was back to clearing my 5’2”.
My senior year was my big year, and probably
where the most superstitions arose. They didn’t necessarily come from
experiences when things went bad, but rather from experiences when things went
good. I was the returning state champ. Lots of pressure all on its own. I was
looking for a scholarship. Add more pressure. I had a goal I wanted to reach
and only one chance to achieve it. My superstition level was at an all-time
high. I was almost to the point of obsession in making sure my routine was the
same as the previous year. Hair- check, chalk- check, warm up routine- check.
The same thing over and over because of the overwhelming fear that everything
would fall apart. As I would continue clearing new heights I would copy what I did
at the meet I upped my height at. The one time I cleared 5’7” I was a mess.
Every little thing stayed the same.
I guess
you could say that the fallacy post hoc was ruling my life. I believe it had a
negative effect because I was too focused on making sure everything was the
same instead of just focusing on what I was doing. It was a lesson well
learned, and while some of the superstitions may follow me to my collegiate
athletic career, they will not rule me. The fallacy was beneficial in providing
me with comfort and familiarity in my endeavors I guess you could say. Even
though that sounds super weird.
Fallacies
are delicate things. Writers and speakers must be cautious in the use of them.
The use of Rhetorical Fallacies may just be a crime to your arugment
I think one of the easiest fallacies
to recognize in writing is oversimplification. This fallacy is mostly noted in
logic explanations, when really the writing doesn't sound logic at all. The writer will state
complex issues and do their best to make the argument seem simple. By doing
this, a lot of important information is left out, even though the argument may
contain truth, it is pretty easy to figure out as a reader when a writer is
trying to make an argument sound simple. They try to make a very broad topic
seem simple and easy, as if it only contained one cause. The cause may be one
of the biggest, but usually in a broad problem, there never is one simple
solution.
This fallacy would be
recognized by the reoccurring word choice that a writer may choose. Since a writer
is trying to make their problem or cause super simple, they will use the same
words over and over. Most likely the words “simple” “easy” or they might just
state to you the answer. A lot of writers use this type of fallacy as a strength
in their writing, and it’s a good tactic to persuade an audience, but too much
of it may be doing the authors whole purpose a crime. Another way to
recognize oversimplification is by just questioning the writing. Is it logic? Does
it flow correctly? Is it in anyway, misleading? If so, then research the topic.
Many writers take advantage of their reader and audience by not stating to them
the whole problem, and overlooking any situation to persuade them into a
certain point.
One time I remember reading an
article and asking myself is this correct? The information didn’t quite flow
together and I spent much time figuring the whole point of the article. Since the
problem was so overlooked, it just didn’t make any sense whatsoever. No background,
no evidence, and no reasons were stated to support the argument and it made me
just re-think the whole article. It did
the writer no good, probably all the time that was spent writing the article
was lost and I do feel bad for them. I think overall oversimplification is an
easy fallacy to notice in writing, and it’s something we should all be aware
about so we don’t get fooled. Writers take advantage of their audiences a lot,
not including the whole truth, or the important information may just jeopardize
your career. Being fooled by this rhetorical fallacy would make me question
someone of course, but sometimes it sounds too good to be true, that you really
will have to search for the truth on your own.
Fallacious Folderol
This one time, way back in the day when I lived off of cold cereal, I got intensely sick. [Spoiler alert: If you can’t see where this is going, you might want to skip a little.] The coup d’état of stirring residents within my gut brought me to my knees. Hunched over a toilet bowl, the musty smell of porcelain swirling in my nostrils commenced the grand finale with a fiesta of flavors, a shindig of scents, and a celebration of colors flamboyantly and fiercely gushing into their early grave. May they rest in peace. They were much too young. Their colors were still vibrant and their texture was so clear I could still see their laughter lines, and their scares of sacrifice. Why would that ambrosia we call Trix betray me? The fear of a coup de grâce to my current illustrious health keeps me from ever wanting to eat Trix, those delectable little devils, ever again.
I am a living, breathing fallacy. I pride my health on not eating Trix. I blame Trix for making me sick. Let me spare you the graphic details, but the most likely reason I was sick was food poisoning from that cheap, open past curfew, restaurant that only my friends’ and my adolescent budgets could afford. Betos.
Even though I am aware that my morning bowl of cereal is unlikely to be the mastermind culprit, I am still buying into the post hoc ergo propter hoc logical fallacy. Or is it an illogical fallacy?
“Post hoc ergo propter hoc” can be roughly translated as, “if A happened before B, A caused B.” In a way this fallacy is best friends with ‘hasty generalization’, but is more of a hasty conclusion. This isn’t quite ‘guilty by association’ either, but it is a slightly similar fallacy of which you are probably more familiar with.
What really separates this fallacy from its friends is its focus on time.
We can see this fallacy almost anywhere, especially in politics, courtroom dramas, or anywhere that people are pinning blame on someone/something. It has happened in the history of American Presidents even. When the economy goes through a change (positive or negative) during any president’s first term it is easy for people to think, “Inauguration happened prior to the change, therefore the president caused the change.” Instead of considering the prior presidents’ policies or other possible factors.
This fallacy can be recognized by asking yourself a few questions every time you see fingers pointed or blame being laid.
Example: “The death of Franz Ferdinand was the cause of WWI.”
Now, I’m no history buff, but this is an actual claim.
Now, I’m no history buff, but this is an actual claim.
Questions: “What are other causes of war?” “What else was taking place around the world?”
“What events led to his death?” “How did those events change after his death?”
I’m not going to claim that his assassination wasn’t a factor in the start of WWI, but it could be easily debated that his death wasn’t THE cause.
“What events led to his death?” “How did those events change after his death?”
I’m not going to claim that his assassination wasn’t a factor in the start of WWI, but it could be easily debated that his death wasn’t THE cause.
In the case of the Archduke I am not so easily persuaded, but in the case of the Trix I am still tricked. A few of use suffered a similar food coup the next day, but because the evidence of the most recent event—eating cereal— was staring me in the face, I am still convinced that it was the cause.
Wednesday, July 16, 2014
Poisoning my well
The Rhetorical Fallacy I chose to talk about is Poisoning The Well. This is a type of ad hominem where the writer instead of attacking the issue really just looks to attack the arguer and any information that the writer uses to argue they try to discredit. I find this to be a pretty affluent fallacy as I see it commonly with people who are my age that get into arguments. There typically really isn't a great quantity of valid information that is being brought forth to argue but the arguer is just discredited and attacked no matter what is said. I find this pretty easy to catch in writing and honestly find it very unattractive when I am trying to believe a source or find validity in a source.
I've experienced this pretty recently in my life. Without getting too personal (don't worry) very recently I dated somebody who was very malicious in the way that she used her words and the way that she would twist my words. Even at times compliments were twisted to use them against me and to discredit what I'd say. For example If I said "You are a really great person with so much potential. You are very caring and thoughtful". Her response to discredit and take away value from what I said would be "Those are just words. You do not mean that. That is not very sincere. You do this, this and this..". This is very frustrating when it is happening in every day dialogue. It does not build trust. Immediately it only starts discord and vehemency. I am not sure that there ever would be a clever or good use of this type of fallacy as It cannot be deemed as valid.
Another example of this I see a lot is on open blog forums. In High School I played football and on Deseret News there was an open blog where people would comment about teams and games that week. One of the weeks against our rivalry I had a very good game and some of the parents had made comments toward me saying that I wasn't "as good as people make me out to be" or "I am a dirty player". These comments were thrown out to attack me and when I responded with "I am sorry, I just play the game as good as I can. If you can show me an example I'd love to change" there were some respondents that just said "Whatever you are dirty and you know it!" Now, these respondents were not looking to really make a valid point put just make me look bad. There is no win when responding to these types of fallacies because there is no much ill intent involved. Just like my prior relationship.
I am not a big fan of fallacies and up to this point choose to stay away from them in my writing.
I've experienced this pretty recently in my life. Without getting too personal (don't worry) very recently I dated somebody who was very malicious in the way that she used her words and the way that she would twist my words. Even at times compliments were twisted to use them against me and to discredit what I'd say. For example If I said "You are a really great person with so much potential. You are very caring and thoughtful". Her response to discredit and take away value from what I said would be "Those are just words. You do not mean that. That is not very sincere. You do this, this and this..". This is very frustrating when it is happening in every day dialogue. It does not build trust. Immediately it only starts discord and vehemency. I am not sure that there ever would be a clever or good use of this type of fallacy as It cannot be deemed as valid.
Another example of this I see a lot is on open blog forums. In High School I played football and on Deseret News there was an open blog where people would comment about teams and games that week. One of the weeks against our rivalry I had a very good game and some of the parents had made comments toward me saying that I wasn't "as good as people make me out to be" or "I am a dirty player". These comments were thrown out to attack me and when I responded with "I am sorry, I just play the game as good as I can. If you can show me an example I'd love to change" there were some respondents that just said "Whatever you are dirty and you know it!" Now, these respondents were not looking to really make a valid point put just make me look bad. There is no win when responding to these types of fallacies because there is no much ill intent involved. Just like my prior relationship.
I am not a big fan of fallacies and up to this point choose to stay away from them in my writing.
Tuesday, July 15, 2014
My personal fallacy-believing false authority
I have a weakness for false authority. False authority, when speaking about rhetorical fallacies, references when somebody tries to use a figure, usually a celebrity, to make a product appeal to the people in terms of “coolness”, not functionality. For example, if you take two deodorant commercials, and one is done by a biochemist, and the other by NBA star Kevin Durant, chances are that the commercial done by Kevin Durant will be “cooler”, or more appealing to the general audience viewing it. Often the audience will be more attracted to buying it when a celebrity they know and idol is using that product. I certainly have a soft spot for these type of ads.
My earliest recollection of being fooled by this type of rhetorical fallacy is in the 4th grade. I remember that around the time of 4th grade I was incredibly obsessed with Tony Hawk, skateboarding, and of course, the PS2 game “Tony Hawk Pro Skater”. I would go to my friend’s house and play that video game, then go out to my friend’s front yard and skateboard. Needless to say, I was obsessed. So it was no surprise when a Tony Hawk sponsored came on that I was instantly intrigued, and instantaneously had a desire to go out and buy the product that he was advertising. I remember vividly what he was advertising, as well. He was advertising Tech Deck (the little finger skateboard) skate shoes. I saw that commercial and immediately went to my Mom and asked to go and buy those shoes. In my family we have a rule that when we were in elementary school, once a year, right before the new school year starts, we could go out and buy new school shoes, in whatever design and style that we wanted. I had already gotten my school shoes for the year, but I was determined nonetheless. I took my carefully saved, and hard earned money to the nearby Wal-Mart and bought those shoes. I wore those with pride to school and to my friend’s house, but to my dismay they were poor quality shoes. They fell apart quickly, weren’t comfortable, and looking back, were not that attractive as well. I should have spent more time at the store looking at them and walking in them, but my mind was so clouded by the image of me wearing the very shoes that Tony Hawk was advertising that I bought them with no hesitation. Needless to say, I was incredibly fooled by the rhetorical fallacy of false authority.
Friday, July 11, 2014
Mistakenly Classified
For my Rhetorical Analysis I chose the article “Behind the
‘Illegal Alien’ Label, Real Kids With A Lot to Contribute” by Marcos Brenton.
In this article Brenton talks about the negative connotations that the phrase
“illegal alien” invokes. It is a broad term that does not flatter all those who
carry it. Brenton argues that individuals that use the term “illegal alien” and
are unaware of the ideas it carries should change their ways. He does this
effectively by using rhetorical devices such as rhetorical questions,
juxtaposing ideas, and […].
Brenton uses juxtaposing ideas of possible jobs to contrast what
careers the “illegal aliens” can have. He says, “But there is a big difference
between a drug dealer and a day laborer. There is a big difference between a
rapist and an honor student” (Brenton 28). Often when the term “illegal alien”
is used we are quick to think drug dealer or rapist, but its forgotten that
there are productive immigrants as well. As Brenton places the contrasting jobs
next to each other the reader is able to see the broad spectrum of types of
immigrants there are. There are still some that are in the country for the
wrong reasons, but they should not stop those who are contributing to our
society. The author’s use of juxtaposing ideas was effective because the reader
is now more open minded and more likely to listen to the claims Brenton makes.
The writer assumes that the audience does not know a lot about
immigrants. This article was written for the Sacramento Bee. Macros Brenton
knows that immigration is a big issue in California. I do think that Brenton is
effective in his argument. He brings up multiple points that open the eyes of
the people who were using the term “illegal alien” loosely. Points such as, not
all immigrants are drug dealers and rapists; they are honor students and day
laborers too. The immigrants are not stealing jobs; they are simply doing the
jobs that Americans do not want to do. There are teenagers that are considered
“illegal aliens” because their parents are immigrants, they have no control of
the situation they were born into. These claims effectively persuade the reader
who uses “illegal alien” and does not understand what they are saying to change
their ways. Readers will now be more cautious in their word choice when the
topic of immigration comes into play.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)