Friday, July 11, 2014

Spider Bites


The first few times I read through Steven Staples article about the relationship between globalization and militarism a few things stood out that I was eager to call him out on. It was very apparent that he was using a web of rhetorical fallacies and the venomous verbiage of a skillful up-talker.

Every time I sat down to write I was fueled with fire and a shoe, ready to brand the authors rhetoric as fraudulent and end the spiders’ career of deceitful spinning. As soon as my pen scribbled the words, “[t]he author [was] ineffective” (Zebra 1) an empty void as large as the pit in my gut emptied my brain. I wanted to claim it was just the authors toxins getting to me, but the arguments I wanted to refute weren’t even claims he made.

Calling his rhetoric ineffective because it is laced in trickery would be paramount to saying a trap door spider isn’t a spider because it uses a less noticeable and more aggressive means to catch its’ prey.

Through the means of open ended examples and usage of words that are either exaggerations or intense pacifiers Stephen Staples is, indeed, very effective in persuading proponents of globalization that their movement towards a greater world economy comes with a price of detrimental consequences.

Staples makes few claims on his own: “[economic] inequality is growing … conflict and wars are emerging[;] it is important to see the connection between [the] two” (Staples 44). Then, by providing supporting evidence about the escalation of wars—to include civil wars—readers stop relying on Staples to provide them with conclusions and begin to interpret the situations on their own. If this happens to you, you best be careful! You are walking into lethal trap. He specifically mentions the results of economic inequality happening in Asia—in 1999—which caused a violent stir with probable use of nuclear weapons (45).

Wait, what? Economic inequality leads to global war? This claim stands out like a sore thumb, possibly sore because it just got bit by the arachnid of rhetoric. Most readers will keep reading without batting an eye, that’s the first symptom of his bite, thinking the argument was their own idea. Staples never makes that heavy of a claim, so yes, the reader came to that conclusion on their own. How wants to debate themselves? If you answered, ‘not me, that’s crazy!’ then you will probably accept that somewhat over-the-top argument because youa came up with it yourself. Rather, you would have if you read Staples’ article and not this one first. If you answered, ‘I won’t debate myself, but I’ll take a spider on any day,’ congratulations, the venom has made you terminal. You are going to disregard the argument altogether wither because it is farfetched or because it isn’t even one of his claims, so instead you will settle for his first and actual claim, “economic inequality is growing”. Ipso facto you are still persuaded, even if it is just a little, by his intricate fallacy.

I think this is the material I will cover in my rhetorical analysis.

"Think Globally, Eat Locally"

   I have chosen to do my rhetorical analysis on article 5-B in the Perspectives on Globalization book. The article is titled "Think Globally, Eat Locally" and was written by Jennifer Wilkins and Anna Lappe. I believe that they chose a very fitting and eye catching title. It sure was what caught my attention.
   In this article the authors present many different ways on how to change eating habits and become healthier and environmental-friendly consumers. They address many different issues and give solutions to each one. By acknowledging so many different problems they widen their audience. It is not just those who have local farmers markets available, or those who buy from a supermarket. By making so many points Wilkins and Lappe increase the chance of having one point that every American can relate to. However, Wilkins and Lappe do generalize their audience by not acknowledging those who have medical issues or special dietary needs.
   When discussing how we can "Quench Thirst With Tap Water" (Wilkins/Lappe 92) they omit the fact that, in some places, tap water may not just be expensive, but perhaps unavailable as well. What about when there is a problem with plumbing? My family recently moved into a new farm house and the first winter we spent there the pipes froze. You could say that our availability to tap water had been frozen in its tracks. While I agree that drinking tap water is much more friendly to the environment, it is not always the most dependable.
   Wilkins and Lappe have a very strong opinion on this topic. Their tone shows that while being professional and well informed, you can still be witty and clever. They are pretty light and casual. Nevertheless, I believe through their use of exaggeration, facts, and solutions they make a very convincing argument on eating locally and changing our dietary course of action.
   The text was written and published in April of 2007 in the Seattle Post-Intelligencer. I recall this being a climax for concerns of global warming. This article was written at a good time for it to influence many readers. It suggests easy ways that we can use less plastic and fossil fuels, as well as positive ways to improve not just the Earth's health, but our own health.
   I thoroughly enjoyed how this article was structured and written. I believe for the most part, the rhetorical devices used are beneficial. Wilkins and Lappe explain things that the readers may not understand. This shows they are aware of their audience and are open to gaining more supporters. Through all the facts, witty comments, and structural writing, this article is a convincing and enjoyable read.

Unnecessarily Spending Green on "Green" Products

            The article from Perspectives on Globalization that I have chosen is “Buying into the Green Movement” by Alex Williams, and yes, that was a piece of my mini-essay in class today. I chose this article because it really caught my attention and it had an argument that I had never thought of before. The article is about some of the unwise misconceptions that some people have on buying green products to save their surrounding environment. Alex Williams discusses how some people think that it is OK to live luxurious lifestyles and use up natural resources as long as the resources they use are “green”. The goal, or rhetorical purpose, of the article is to convert “eco-sensitive” consumers into a new mindset on their buying habits. He wants to have consumers stop wasting their money on green products because they are not the solution to damage to the environment.
            I think that he effectively convinces the audience to realize the fault in their actions because he has a greatly interesting writing style and uses good rhetorical tools. The first thing that popped out to me was his use of irony and sarcasm to get a point across. One specific ironic thing that he discusses is the way that consumers will buy organic raspberries in the winter because they are organic without realizing that those raspberries are being flown in on a Boeing 747 from Chile and using lots of jet fuel. The thought of buying products that are good for the environment is great but Williams shows that sometimes the logic behind it can be missing.

            Alex Williams also does a great job of describing the situations that can occur through the use of exemplum. He gives lots of possible situations that eco-sensitive consumers have either done or seen others do. By doing this, he is able to relate to the readers and the readers are more willing to listen when they admit in their minds that they are guilty of some of the actions mentioned. One example of exemplum is when he says public people try to help the environment by turning down the environment, driving smaller cars, and carrying a cloth “Save-a-Tree” tote to the supermarket (Williams 103). I think most people have turned their thermostats down, considered buying a smaller car, and seen other people using cloth grocery bags in their town before. That is why this rhetorical tool is effective in capturing the reader’s attention and convincing “eco-sensitive” consumers to change their buying habits.

Wal-Martians Invasion

For my rhetorical analysis I chose to analyze Barbara Ehrenreich article called “Wal-Martians Invasion”. Her purpose for writing this article is to inform people that not only is Wal-Mart taking over the world and creating hard, physical, and strenuous task to its employees. I think that she effectively persuades her the people of Baltimore that Wal-Mart does not value its employees through allusion, enumeration, and tone. She assumes that the audience, citizens of America will take a stand against a company that’s in contrary with the principle that America was founded on such as liberty, and justice. This assumption is very significant because most Americans have a strong belief against child labor laws in third world countries such as Africa. If they’re so passionate about something that’s not in their country then when the same problem arises in their own country they would be even more passionate to fight the cause.
Ehrenreich’s humorous tone throughout the article connects with the reader by making smiles between Wal-Mart and Aliens landing on earth. Later in her article Ehrenreich made a comment that showed how serious the situation was. She compares the cost of Wal-Mart’s insurance to the price of their faded glory jeans. The world would consider their jeans to be really cheap. By doing this the author puts it into perspective just how much cruel laboring that Wal-Mart customers face. This type of humor leaves a seriousness and retentive statement in the readers mind. From her background and other publications she is well known for her humor in different articles and her participation in many feminist groups.
She’s really effective in providing many facts for her argument but I think she was ineffective for providing solutions. She asked the audience “But who is prepared to step forward and show Wal-Mart how to coexist with the people of its choses planet?” Though she brings up people who are not prepared to help with the cause because of their promotion towards the argument she doesn’t give her readers a plan on how they can stop Wal-Mart’s disillusion they put towards the U.S. on treating their employees.


Overall I think the author did a good job of capturing the audience attention with all the comparison she makes with aliens. By taking this approach it allowed readers to be the aggressors which created desire to continue reading. Doing this also, the argument will resonate more with the readers and have a lasting effect on them than someone just taking a really aggressive approach by laying cold hard facts. 

Rhetorical analysis on Think Globally, Eat Locally

            My rhetorical analysis will be on “Think Globally, Eat Locally” by Jennifer Wilkins and Anna Lappe. In the article, Wilkins and Lappe rely heavily on comparative imagery in order, it seems, to try to make their audience, the American public, feel guilty about how our eating habits affect the global climate. They discuss how we waste large amounts of resources, such as food and land, in order to produce and distribute various parts of our diet that we don’t actually need. Wilkins’ and Lappe’s use of extreme comparisons, such as between shipping fresh tomatoes to New Jersey with driving an 18-wheeler to the moon over a dozen times, work to create a sense of guilt in anyone who has at least considered the fact that burning fossil fuels negatively affects Earth’s climate. If they don’t feel that, I’m sure they at least feel the pain in their wallet after realizing how much that would cost.
One assumption that Wilkins and Lappe seem to make, based on how varied the topics they discuss are, is that Americans are very diverse in what our eating habits are. By discussing such ideas as eating locally and seasonally, they manage to connect with people who, although they have access to locally grown food, tend to buy food that has instead traveled perhaps a few thousand miles just to get to them. Of course, if this were the only route the writers went in showing how we can improve, then they would be isolating those Americans who live in places where food either isn’t or can’t be grown locally to any real extent, such as Alaska. However, they (Wilkins and Lappe) manage to address all their readers by continuing with other topics that do apply to the different areas. Some example of what they talk about that can be applied to nearly all Americans are our junk food and soda habits, as well as our habit to eat more than necessary. By branching out into so many parts of how we eat, they manage to keep each reader focused on looking for ways in which they can change, even though they might exclude themselves from one or two of the given topics.

To conclude, Wilkins and Lappe successfully manage to connect with an impressively wide range of American readers by accounting for so many different eating styles and habits, and having connected with their readers, they proceed to pull hard at their hearts with strong imagery of the waste we go through just to keep those habits. They don’t leave much room for people to excuse themselves from finding at least one way they can eat cleaner.

Behind the Illegal Alien Label Rhetorical Analysis

Behind the Illegal Alien Label Rhetorical Analysis

For my rhetorical analysis I chose to write about Marcos Brenton’s “Behind the ‘Illegal Alien’ Label: Real Kids With A Lot to Contribute”. In the writing Brenton passionately tries to make his readers understand why it is inappropriate for all non-American citizens to be referred to as ‘illegal aliens’.  Through the use of many rhetorical devices, such as personification and rhetorical questioning, he captivates the audiences’ attention and forces them to think critically about the argument he is trying to make. 
At times his argument may turn off his readers because he criticizes them strongly but he brings them back by forming questions to make them realize his point. Brenton’s main audience is American people.  In one instance he states, “ I dare some of you to take a ride up to the Yuba City area in July when it’s good and hot so you can pick melons all stooped over and moving as fast as you can to keep up with the real workers. Good luck.” Brenton’s sarcastic tone gives could annoy some readers because he is wanting to make them see his side but is not being overly sensitive to their side either. His statement is insinuating that American are not hard working when it comes to manual labor and therefore we have to use the aid of immigrants to help in keeping some aspects of our country going. 
Though in my opinion he does an adequate job of convincing the audience that not all non-American citizens are criminals and should not be deemed the title ‘illegal alien’, he doesn’t convince the audience that immigrants should be given the same opportunity in our work force as American citizens. I believe that non-American citizens should be allowed to gain an education in the U.S. but be pushed toward to returning to their home country and using their education to uplift their home. All in all I feel that the audience could be divided on what side of the idea they stand based on their personal beliefs prior to reading this essay. I feel Brenton was unable to persuade the audience toward his side because of the criticism he placed on American citizens.



Enlightening the World; AIDS and India, Melinda French Gates

            Here is a brief free-write of just a few of the obvious literary devices I saw immediately. I hope to encourage readers to realize how important this knowledge is to society, as well as, take a stand and assist in the terminating of this world-wide issue. I also hope to point out a few instances where the author could’ve been more precise in their writing to further persuade readers.  
Gates’ article, AIDS and India, was both informative and encouraging. Gates wrote to a world-wide audience as she displayed the hard facts of reality.  Her purpose in writing, being to bring to attention, the harsh truth of the happenings in India. As well as, to inspire readers to take a stand and make a difference. Gates uses a variety of literary devices to appeal to her desired audience, as well as deep, hidden emotion that can be read between the lines.
            Melinda Gates, wife of the infamous Bill Gates, stated that she and her husband started a foundation based on the shared belief that every child in this world deserves a chance at good health. The reality being, “more than 10 million children die every year, and two-thirds of them are dying from diseases that could be prevented with low-cost intervention.” Here, Gates uses both pathos and hard evidence to demand attention and call to action. She firmly states her ideal goal, “…every child deserves a chance at good health.” While also explaining that this ideal is a very possible goal to accomplish, “…dying from diseases that could be prevented with low-cost intervention.” The heartbreaking problem is clearly displayed and the solution, simple.
            Gates gave multiple solutions to this horrific problem. For those who are financially willing and able, she extended the invitation, to donate to Global Fund- an organization designed to help fight AIDS. Additionally, catering to all people, no matter their status, Gates also gives us a friendly reminder to educate those around us about the disease and its harmful effects.
            I stand alongside Melinda Gates as I too, am confident that “India can prevail against AIDS.” The result being, that children with thrive, economies will boom, democracies will flourish…” as we together make a difference. Let us be informed, let us educate, and let us be empowered so we too may empower others. Together we can overcome the odds.