Friday, July 18, 2014

You're ugly so that fallacy didn't work.

The fallacy I chose was ad hominem. Ad hominem when translated into English means “against the man.” Like the definition implies ad hominem is when the arguer attacks someone’s character instead of addressing the argument. When they do this they appeal to emotions instead of using intellect. Ad hominem is most often found in political debates between politicians.
            This past election was one of the first I actually sat down to watch because of my government class. I began noticing ad hominem coming from both of the candidates. When a question was asked instead of addressing the question the candidate would throw in “Well he is not reliable because of such and such…” and “He can not be trust because if that one time.” For example this is part of the second presidential debate between Romney and Obama. The host asks a question about citizens that are long-termed employed and need jobs right now, which Romney answer and this is Obama’s response after, “And Governor Romney says he's got a five-point plan. Governor Romney doesn't have a five-point plan; he has a one-point plan. And that plan is to make sure that folks at the top play by a different set of rules. That's been his philosophy in the private sector; that's been his philosophy as governor; that's been his philosophy as a presidential candidate.” Obama attacks Romney and never actually address what he would do in the situation. Therefore, Romney looks bad in the eyes of the audience, but those who catch this fallacy realize that Obama never actually answered the question at hand.
I was not fooled by this fallacy because we had talked about it in my writing class and I could see the tactics the candidates were using. It was not effective for me and it honestly put down both of the men in my opinion. Instead of coming up with intellectual answers like men they reverted back to their childhood days of “You are ugly so you are wrong.”   

Although, I can see if someone were to be fooled by this fallacy the effect it would have on him or her. They would take into account all the “bad” things that the candidates did and would make a judgment on their character. While character is important part of the election process I would much rather hear where they stood on the issues of our society instead of hear about the one time either had a slip up.

Anti-hunters are baby killers?

            The rhetorical fallacy that I have chosen is “guilt by association.” It consists of judging or attacking a person solely based on their affiliation with a specific group. The idea is that, because certain members of a group do certain unpopular or bad things, all members of the group are involved in those things, therefore this specific member is also involved and is a bad person. It destroys the person’s (or group’s) authority by immediately painting them in a bad light in mind of the reader. It is a fallacy because of how blatantly wrong it can be and most of the time is.

            An example of when I saw this was a few weeks back when I was reading an article about people who are anti-hunting. The author was trying to prove his point that people shouldn’t judge those who go hunting. He started out well by describing the different reasons people hunt and the benefits that certain styles of hunting can give. But then he tries to discredit the people who verbally attack those who hunt by using this “guilt by association.” He makes the assumption that all those who are saying that it’s horrible to go out and kill animals are the same people that say it’s perfectly ok to kill babies if they haven’t been born yet. He tries to make the point that it’s completely ridiculous that they would support animal rights and yet negate rights to members of their own species. However, it’s extremely unlikely that all people who fall into the one group are also in the other, so it makes it a completely unfair connection and ruins the image of those who are pro animal rights in the mind of the reader. When I first read the article I didn’t really think about this bit too much at the time. It wasn’t until I was reading some of the comments on it about how arrogant the author was to say such a thing that I realized how detrimental it actually was, and not so much to the group he was attacking as to his actual article. It made him seem like he couldn’t find anything real against the actual group he was attacking (the pro-animal people) so all he could do was associate them with an entirely different group to paint them in as negative a light as possible. Hopefully in the future I will recognize such errors on my own, rather than having to rely on comments by other people that point out those errors.

Ethos Fallacy - Guilt by Association

The fallacy that I chose comes from one of ethos fallacies. Guilt by association is an attack on an individual’s credibility based upon that individual’s association with a particular group. The most common well known example of this fallacy is racism. Yes think about it. Racism results in someone doing something that was maybe an offense to someone else. Because of that the identified race is held accountable or is perceived to do the same. I think that this fallacy can be easily identified if the author can’t provide sufficient evidence. If the accusation is because of past incidents with the same racial group than this is a guilt by association fallacy.
 A time that I was encountered by this fallacy is one my mission in England. In England there is a stereotype associated with people from Romania. These specific people are referred to as Gypsies. Known by the people of England to steal anything that they can get their hands on. That’s right you name it, from your personal t.v to wallet from your pants while they are starring at you in the eyes and talking to you. Every time we ate over members house and they asked who were in our teaching pool. As we would tell them that we were teaching all kinds of people: Chinese, English, Polish and Portuguese. Their response would be “Good, as long as you’re not teaching any Gypsies.” One day we got a referral from a member and we meet up with the referral at his work. As we approach his place of work, a car wash we realize that he was a Gypsie. Along with him was his brother, uncle and friend. We had two options, we could either not teach them or we could give it a shot. We decided to teach them after all. As we returned for the second appointment the new Gypsie investigators had referred 10 new people to us. They all wanted to hear about the gospel. They came to activities and church and absolutely loved it. The members were totally surprised that they didn't meet the stereotype that they all had associated with Gypsies. If my and companion and I had decided to go along with what we heard about the Romanian group then we would have never gotten 14 new investigators in one week.

 I think that the ethos fallacy, guilt by association is easy to recognize because of the association that one is acclaimed to because of her or her ethnic or racial group. Throughout my life I have known about this fallacy without actually knowing that it’s been occurring throughout years of history.

Does your mom know you're gay?

            The fallacy that I have fallen for before is one that I was exposed to way back in my playground days. The fallacy I am referring to is that of a complex or “loaded” question.  A loaded question is a question with a false or questionable presupposition, and it is "loaded" with that presumption. Loaded questions are bad things because they are really asking two questions at once. The purpose of a preloaded question is for the author to assume something and trick the reader into believing that one of the questions pre-assumed is already true. One thing that I found online was interesting. It said, “because a question is not an argument, simply asking a loaded question is not a fallacious argument. Rather, loaded questions are typically used to trick someone into implying something they did not intend”.
            The first time I was exposed to a loaded question, I was not aware that it was a loaded question. It was an immature, yet still funny, playground trick that we as kids used to play on each other. The trick would start out with two simple questions. The first question was, “Are you gay?” The person being asked the questions would then answer, “No”. The next question was, “Have you ever been gay?” This, of course, was also followed by a “No”. Both of these questions were simple enough, but then the next question was loaded and it came in for the knockout. The question was, “Does your mom know you’re gay?” At this point, the person being questioned was stuck in a bit of a catch-22 situation. Either way he answered, he would leave his friends giggling. If he answered Yes, he was gay and his mom was aware of it. If he answered No, he was gay but his mom just hadn’t found out yet. I was definitely fooled by this fallacy’s fallaciousness. Although some of the homosexual community may have found this trick to be borderline immature and offensive, it is important to realize that we were all young boys –  both immature and offensive.

            Besides making me laugh when I was younger, it stuck into my brain as a fallacy and it has been an effective tool in my learning process. The problem with the question was that it was implying two questions into one: “Are you gay?” and “If so, is your mom aware of it?” By splitting it into two questions, it eliminates both questions. In my writing, readings, and interactions with others through speeches and conversation, I will have to learn to recognize this type of fallacy and the trap it is able to set. 

False Authority


False Authority

The fallacies of ethos are the group of fallacies I would feel most comfortable using in my writing simply because I am the author. To me it’s easier to manipulate people into believing something about another person or to be persuaded by the authority of another person. False authority is a fallacy of ethos that occurs when an author tries to trick the audience into over estimating their (the authors) creditability. It also can refer to using a celebrity or other educated person to advertise or testify of something that they are not knowledgeable about.  One example of the false authority fallacy I have seen is the Proactive commercials. Proactive is an acne medication so if the company wanted to have the most knowledgeable people advertising for them they would most likely want to use dermatologists and chemist to explain the science of the product and what makes it so different and have faster results than other face cleansing products. However this is not what the company does. Instead they hire celebrities to endorse their product. The celebrities attest to using the product and raving about how amazing the product is and all that it has done for them. Whether or not the celebrities actually used the product or if it even worked could never be known by the audience. Though I have been manipulated into wanting to try other things endorsed by people in the media, I have never believed that the Proactive commercials were real or reliable. Its obvious that the company is probably just paying the celebrities to endorse their product because they know it will sell better that way as compared to having dermatologist talking about it. Celebrities wear immense amounts of make-up so there is no true way of knowing if they ever had bad acne or not.

Strawpeople



My favorite fallacy is strawperson.  Mostly because I really like the name.   But also because it is common.  A straw person is another's viewpoint that has been oversimplified and made so that it is easy to refute.  This rhetorical fallacy is common amongst writers who don't have a strong argument to begin with.  Their only resort is to attempt to weaken or challenge the opposite viewpoint.

Strawpeople can be hard to identify.  Really fallacious writers can be very manipulative and make the reader believe that the enemy’s point of view is ridiculous or insane.  That is why the first step in being a strawperson fallacy detective is to be be wary of any time you led to believe that the so-and-so must be completely crazy if he really believes this or that.  This is an easy indicator for anyone who is trying to knock down a strawperson.  Most legitimate aren’t that simple.  They are complex.  And complex arguments require well thought-out solutions.  So if a complex issue is being addressed and the opposite view is being made to seem ridiculous, be careful of strawpeople.

I have encountered strawpeople many a time in my brief existence on this planet. One of my most recent encounters was in a classroom setting.  Studying fallacies in Writing 150, we read an article by Matt Walsh.  In this article, Walsh used a plethora of strawpeople, making everyone of a different viewpoint from his seem like their brain waves weren’t functioning properly.  Even the title of his article, “Isn’t it mean and hateful to deport illegal immigrants?” draws attention to the opposite viewpoint: that deporting illegal immigrants is not bad.  But his argument is that it is not bad.  And he makes this clear very early on.  Then he spends the entire introductory phase of his article - about a very controversial matter, mind you - making it out to seem that the matter is very simple and that his solution is the only logical answer.  The rest of the article is Welsh attacking the opposite viewpoint.  To be 100%, I was not fooled by this fallacy.  Either I am fallacy-proof or it was magnitude of this fallacy that gave it away, but I think it was the latter.

So, in conclusion, if you ever come across an argument that doesn’t give a whole ton of evidence for it’s claim, but, on the other hand, plenty of evidence against the rebuttal, watch out.  You just might have encountered a strawperson.

False Authority

       The fallacy of ethos, false authority, is observed when an author has no authority or credibility in what they are saying, yet he or she attempts to come across as having authority. False authority is persistently used in the media and advertisements of today's time. We see famous performers endorsing products that have no relation to their occupations and field of knowledge. This is certainly not by accident. We live in a time where famous people are glorified to such an extent that people literally desire to be them. Therefore, such a fallacy is found to be very effective when used to sell products. If you have the chemists who created the newest skin cream explain why the product is effective in a commercial, chances are, you would lose the attention of your intended audience. However, if you have Carrie Underwood using the product with a few smiles and hair flips, people will undoubtedly consider the product. It does not matter that Carrie most likely knows nothing behind the formulation of the product, it just matters that she is beautiful and is using the product. 
      In order to effectively identify this fallacy, it is key for me to persistently ask myself the question, "can I trust this person?," whether it is in media or writing. The answer to this question will obviously not just come to me unless I already know the author background. This will require some research. It will be important to find out if the author has any experience related to the topic being addresed. Some individuals have a way with words and can convince anyone of anything, but if I educate myself about the author, his ability to convince will either increase or decrease. The same goes for advertisements in media. Ask myself something similar to, "Is she a chemist? Or a very attractive singer?." 
      I recently viewed an icy hot commercial in which Shaquille O'neal was the endorser. Many athletes, especially basketball players, look up to Shaquille as a legend. Seeing him use icy hot likely caught the attention of these athletes, and persuaded them to consider the product. I'm not certain, but I'm pretty sure Shaquille's smile doesn't explain why or how icy hot works. This commercial left me unpersuaded; however, I'm convinced this is not the case for all. There have been times that my attention has been drawn to certain products because of the popularity of the people promoting them; therefore, false authority is a very effective fallacy. Hence, the frequent use of it in our society.