I have chosen to analyze BG’s article called “Does
Twitter Promote Democracy?” The author
is trying to convince people into politics that also prefer to use social media
that it is not the most effective way of communication and does not go faster. BG
uses an illusion and enumeratio ineffectively to convince social media user’s,
interested in politics, that the use of social media to communicate with
government leaders is only works on a small scale with local leaders. However,
the use of a rhetorical questions helps him get his point across to his
audience. In the end the author was effective at showing getting their point
across. BG uses an enumeratio comparing emails, tweeting, and other forms of
social media to the process a letter goes through before a political leader
sees it. The author does well explaining the letter process, however, how
social media works remains a mystery. The
author presumes that the reader will understand how social media communication
works, which does make since for his audience. However, presuming that social
media would go through the same process as a letter instead of using facts
weakens the author’s argument. It could also leave social media users confused
about how the two are comparable. The use of an allusion comparing social media
to “snail mail” is effective in that it grabs the reader’s attention. However,
it is confusing because it makes the authors argument unclear. Though the use
of an enumeratio and an illusion makes his argument weak the use of a hyperbola
helps the author’s argument become clearer. The author asks, “Does … Chile’s president
have a process in place to manage his Twitter conversation [?]” (BG 110). This
question helps the reader to feel more engaged in the article and explains why
the author did not explain how whether or not social media and letters were the
same earlier in the article. The author then proceeds to answer their own
question by saying that it would only make since. The author becomes speaks
more personally as he explains that though Chile’s president could find a few
good ideas from social media it would be impossible to read every single social
media post or comment sent to him. This makes the explanation using the letter
make more since because if the president of the United States receives 20,000
letters per day just imagine how many social media conversations he receives. In
the end the rhetorical question to bring his argument together and convince
social media users that communication directly to political users using social
media only works on a small scale.
Friday, July 11, 2014
Rhetorical Analysis Post
In his article, "Put Your Money Where Their Mouths Are," Nicholas D. Kristof attacks the current democratic solution to ending global child labor issues. He addresses modern democrats and humanitarians, telling them that protesting against child labor with the intention to end it really does nothing for the children who have fallen victim to it. In fact, children and families across the globe rely on the money made through child labor. Strictly prohibiting child labor actually does more harm to these children. Kristof proposes that instead putting all efforts into fighting against it, democrats need to worry more about getting these kids into school. Kristof suggests that the best way to do his is bribery. Many of these children have spent their lives in hunger so they will go anywhere they can find food. Therefore, to get these kids to school, Kristof encourages his audience to donate money to organizations that provide these schools with food. Instead of ending child labor and leaving them with nothing, the action of getting these children in school will provide them with the lasting benefits associated with having an education.
Kristof is extremely effective at convincing his audience of republican university students that he has a valid solution for fighting against child labor, at least he is to me. As a republican, it caught my attention and obtained my agreement when Kristof highlights the lack of logic in the modern democratic solution in fighting against child labor. He argues that it makes no sense to end child labor and call it good. That simply leaves the children with no productivity in their lives; therefore, it makes sense to get the children out of labor, but also give them an eduction.
In succeeding to capture his audience's emotions, Kristof shares the personal circumstances of different children around the world. Many of these children come from very difficult circumstances and Kristof is very effective at making that clear. Sharing the lives of these children with his audience certainly builds to their sympathy. This causes his audience to feel morally obligated to help these children out by donating, which is ultimately his purpose in writing the article.
Kristofs argument is very aggressive towards democrats, but also very effective because he has credible sources to back up his claim. He presents multiple numbers and statistics that illustrate the magnitude of the global child labor issue. One of the most effective numbers he presents is the cost to feed one child per day, nineteen cents. Such a low price helps his audience understand that they really can donate and make a difference. It also provides a sense of hope for the children that we read about having very difficult circumstances.
Kristof is extremely effective at convincing his audience of republican university students that he has a valid solution for fighting against child labor, at least he is to me. As a republican, it caught my attention and obtained my agreement when Kristof highlights the lack of logic in the modern democratic solution in fighting against child labor. He argues that it makes no sense to end child labor and call it good. That simply leaves the children with no productivity in their lives; therefore, it makes sense to get the children out of labor, but also give them an eduction.
In succeeding to capture his audience's emotions, Kristof shares the personal circumstances of different children around the world. Many of these children come from very difficult circumstances and Kristof is very effective at making that clear. Sharing the lives of these children with his audience certainly builds to their sympathy. This causes his audience to feel morally obligated to help these children out by donating, which is ultimately his purpose in writing the article.
Kristofs argument is very aggressive towards democrats, but also very effective because he has credible sources to back up his claim. He presents multiple numbers and statistics that illustrate the magnitude of the global child labor issue. One of the most effective numbers he presents is the cost to feed one child per day, nineteen cents. Such a low price helps his audience understand that they really can donate and make a difference. It also provides a sense of hope for the children that we read about having very difficult circumstances.
Landon's RA plan of Wal-Martian Invasion
For
my Rhetorical Analysis I chose Barbara Ehrenreich’s article entitled Wal-Martian Invasion. Ehrenreich
attempts to reach her American audience with the use of many rhetorical
devices. These devices include extended analogy, multiple metaphors and
comparative hyperboles that will make you laugh and cringe at the same time.
Ehrenreich effectively uses these devices as she makes her stance clear but not
overbearing. Her use of an extended analogy, comparing Wal-Mart to alien
invaders, is true genius. While at first the analogy comes off a bit childish
and immature it quickly becomes the perfect way for Ehrenreich to express her
opinions on the disconnect between Wal-Mart and the rest of the world. From her
title Wal-Martian Invasion to the
concluding sentence “Earth to Wal-Mars, or wherever you come from: Live with us
or go back to the mother ship” (Ehrenreich 90) she develops a well formulated
idea on the image that Wal-Mart is not your friendly neighborhood grocer.
Ehrenreich also uses a variety of metaphors in order to drive her point home. For
example, in the body of her article Ehrenreich compares Wal-Mart to a starving
hyena. This puts a comical and disturbing image in the head of the reader. By using
this metaphor she is able to paint this greedy thoughtless beast in the readers
heads and evoke a certain fear that merely saying that Wal-Mart is greedy just wouldn’t
do. The last rhetorical device that I chose to analyze was Ehrenreich’s use of
comparative hyperboles. While this device was far less evident than the others,
the effectiveness of it is just as strong. One of her strongest comparisons is
seen in the fourth paragraph. Ehrenreich compares the prices of health
insurance to the prices of faded glory jeans. This is comical, given that faded
glory is already a knock off brand and is considered cheap, and health
insurance is always a daunting bill. Her use of this comparison effectively evokes
fear in the heart of the reader. While it makes one laugh in the moment, it then
makes one think shortly after. Thoughts like “if they can’t even afford cheap
pants then how could they possibly afford insurance?” flood the mind of the
reader. Ehrenreich is very effective in her writing. Her style is enjoyable and
stimulating as well as informative. Her uses of rhetoric very effectively draws
the reader in and makes the reader care about the issue conveyed before them. All
in all, Wal-Martian Invasion is a
very enjoyable and convincing read.
Thursday, July 10, 2014
The Globalization of Poverty in my analysis eyes
This article written by Antonia Juhasz is trying to show that globalization does not help end poverty worldwide and it is not a counter to terrorism but it indeed is the opposite that can cause terrorism and can cause poverty. Antonia started off the article with some emotionalties to Americans when He brought up the Bush administration using September 11th as a ploy to leverage the idea of expanding global trade and to further push globalization by saying that it will be a huge way to stop terrosism. That brought me in emotionally to want to read more because I feel like I am loyal to America and I wanted to see more of what he was going to say. From that point on I didn't really feel emotionally tied into the article anymore I felt like i was bombarded with fact after fact after fact and many quotes that I understood how he was using that to show his point but I wasn't necessarily as interested as I would have liked to have been. I do feel that the article was effective in the way that he does show lots of evidence. I don't think that he wrote anything that was going to initiate any extreme change taking place because of the way that he wrote. I think he should have continued with a lot more emotion on the subject.
I think for the most part that he had a neutral view and showed that he wasn't for any one particular political party or religion and that may have given him some validity on being able to present something that ties into the world. I don't however feel like anything terribly soul shaking or new was being brought to my attention causing me to not have a huge opinion that has changed. I feel like his point was made but not in an urgent way. The title used in "The globalization of Poverty" suggests a strong opinion from the beginning. I felt at times he was a tad myopic in his view. He didn't give any of the other side of the fence and that would have provided more perspective to me as a reader in this case. That would have been my last thing I would have hoped to see. This wasn't terribly interesting to me but enough in the fact that I am in business and I will always be wanting to know about the effects of globalilzation on people and not just business.
I think for the most part that he had a neutral view and showed that he wasn't for any one particular political party or religion and that may have given him some validity on being able to present something that ties into the world. I don't however feel like anything terribly soul shaking or new was being brought to my attention causing me to not have a huge opinion that has changed. I feel like his point was made but not in an urgent way. The title used in "The globalization of Poverty" suggests a strong opinion from the beginning. I felt at times he was a tad myopic in his view. He didn't give any of the other side of the fence and that would have provided more perspective to me as a reader in this case. That would have been my last thing I would have hoped to see. This wasn't terribly interesting to me but enough in the fact that I am in business and I will always be wanting to know about the effects of globalilzation on people and not just business.
To Buy or Not to Buy
I’ve chosen to write my Rhetorical
Analysis about the article entitled “Buying Into the Green Movement” by Alex
Williams. In this article, Alex writes
to all consumers about the need, not only to consume eco-sensitively, but also
to consume less. He attacks those who
have developed the mind-set that as long as they make eco-friendly purchases,
they can consume just as much as they always have. He stays on this topic for about the first
half of the article. Then, the author
transitions into the subject of how those who make eco-conscious decisions, no
matter how much they do or do not sacrifice, are on to something. He argues that those who are engaged in
eco-friendly practices are intrinsically “more committed to more transformative
political action on global warming.”
Alex also states that in the end, it is political action, and not
individual consumer choices, that will make the difference in saving this
planet.
The article is informative, but
unfortunately, I didn’t find it very effective because the note that he started
the article on – playful, sarcastic – was completely different from that which
he ended it on – more serious. He seemed
hesitant or unsure in his rhetorical approach.
Also, the article doesn’t offer any plans of action or solutions, as they
are offered in the much more effective “An Inconvenient Truth”. The whole tone of the article was, “Yeah, we
should consume less but, in the end, the government is eventually going to have
to take care of the problem.” Sure, he
compiled great sources and included some witty phrases, but I do not feel that
this article was effective in convincing its intended audience. One of the biggest reasons why not is that he
first condemns green consumers and then he condones them. He starts by poking fun at the “light greens”
in a condescending way, and by the end of the article he is saying that they’re
on to something. Alex has a good set of
credible sources in his article, but he does a poor job in organizing his
citations and thoughts into creating an article that might have been more
effective in arguing his thesis. Yet, in
the end, his greatest error lies in the fact that he doesn’t stay loyal to his
underdeveloped thesis. This leaves the
reader, upon finishing the article, a bit confused about what to think and what
the author is really trying to convince them to explicitly do.
Rhetorical Analysis
The
article I have chosen to analyze is “Behind the ‘Illegal Alien’ label Real Kids
with a lot to Contribute.” The author’s rhetorical purpose is to show the
audience, mainly Americans and the American government, those who we label as “illegal
immigrants” or “illegal aliens” have a lot to contribute. The author gives a
lot of points stating different ways these immigrants can contribute to the American
society.
The author
writes this article expecting the reader to know: America has a lot to offer
families and individuals success in their lives. There is such a desire that so
many people want a better life for themselves, that it’s crazy how much work
they put in to achieve things, us as Americans see as “minimum.”
The
author uses a lot of different points to express his feelings, add emotion, and
paint a lot of pictures in our minds about this situation. I think the author
succeeds at convincing us that the “Illegal Alien” has a lot more to offer to society
that we may know of. As Americans we typically stereotype the words “illegal
alien” and “illegal immigrants,” and give it a negative consequence. We don’t really
realize that most of these “illegal persona,” are doing some of the most extraordinary
things. Throughout the article he hints a lot of the times that we “label” these
immigrants negatively. He does not only make us feel guilty, but he relieves
us, and shows us that we may not think the way our government thinks and acts. The
author leans towards a particular culture, that I think kind of hurts his
argument, but still it helps him a lot to give us an inside look on the way
things happen.
One of my
favorite things the author states is at the end of the whole article, once he
is done explaining his argument. He basically sums it up to 7 words, and kind
of leaves us hanging. To me it is a very emotional article that lists many points
to the reader and puts a bullet right through the American government. I think
immigration is a global issue that may have a lot of different perspectives around
the world, and the way Americans deal with this issue, is very unfair.
This author
does not only just speak about immigration though. He uses children to identify
his points. He compares a drug dealer to a honor student. As a society we see
drug dealers as bad people, who are bad influences, but we look at honor
students and we think they are the wisest, smartest people we know. I really enjoyed that comparison, and hope to
be able to do this article its justice.
Wednesday, July 9, 2014
Rhetorical Analysis Blog Post
For my Rhetorical Analysis I have chosen to write on the article “Wal-Martian Invasion” by Barbara Ehrenreich. The rhetorical purpose in this article is a little unclear to me, to be honest. She spends the whole time bashing on Wal-Mart for various reasons--low pay, high expansion rates, and even calling Wal-Mart a sweatshop-- but I’m still trying to figure out why. Upon my first reading of the article, I was of the thought that it was because she was writing to Wal-Mart executives because she wanted them to change their business practices. While this could still be true, I personally believe that she was just writing to the general public, but especially those who semi-begrudgingly shop at Wal-Mart, as her primary audience, with those Wal-Mart executives as her secondary audience, perhaps. Let me explain. Why would she do this?
I believe the answer is that she knows that she cannot change the practices of Wal-Mart as a company on a whole scale, but what she can do through writing this article is expose Wal-Mart’s weak points, which are points that the general public rarely see. What she accomplishes by doing this is she can convince some people of Wal-Marts bad spots, and there is enough competition in the supermarket business that prices are relatively comparative, and she is hoping that the people who read will go to another store instead of Wal-Mart. I think that the author understands this, and knows that this is the one way that she personally, through writing this article, can have an effect on Wal-Mart as a company: by convincing it’s “on the fence” shoppers to go elsewhere to shop. Less shoppers mean less revenue, effectively hurting Wal-Mart as a whole, which the author obviously has a bias against.
I think that as a whole, she did a good job at her intended audience. I loved her personal experience that she shared about when she worked at Wal-Mart. Although there wasn’t too much detail included in it, just the mere mention of “when I worked at Wal-Mart” showed me, as the reader, that she had a personal connection, and it immediately gave her authority. I felt like I could trust what she had to say. Also, throughout the whole article she used the metaphor of Wal-Mart stores being aliens, with a lot of sarcasm and tone, which made it that much more fun to read. However I didn’t feel like it was all that effective, at least for me anyways. I don’t feel any less inclined to shopping at Wal-Mart. I feel like she was over-exaggerating everything, and I personally don’t feel like Wal-Mart is all that bad of a company. So overall it wasn’t that effective, but the literary devices she used were top-notch.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)